I tuned into am interesting interview on CBC radio today featuring neuroscientist Daniel Levitin in conversation with host Matt Galloway.
In the course of the conversation, they discuss a number of matters related to how music impacts various parts of the brain. They also review the effects of music on people with Parkinson’s, MS, Aspergers, stuttering and more. His work points to the power of music as medicine and how it helped his friend, Joni Mitchell, recover from a brain aneurysm.
Fascinating discussion. Might we see doctors soon prescribe music as medicine? I’ll gladly take a script!
I’m befuddled. Would you humour me dear reader and watch the one-minute public service announcement before continuing to read today’s post. I’d be curious your take on it before being drawn into any debate!
I’ll just wait here for a minute. Just click “Play” key in the above image. Perhaps turn up the volume if you dig Beck like I do.
I’m just waiting. Take the full minute and enjoy. I’m not going anywhere. Really!
Welcome back! So what did you think? Would love to hear your thoughts. As for me, I had mixed feelings about this one. I wanted to like this ad – the catchy upbeat tune, the interaction between the man and the woman (his smile particularly) , the “swag” the character exudes. It is a slap in the face to any stigma that PwP experience. That’s all good! It’s fun. It’s humorous and believe me. living with the moniker ‘imshakydad’ for the past 24+ years, I can appreciate the importance of humour in coping with PD!
On the other hand, there’s a part of me that makes me want to rage against it. Parkinson’s is more – much much more – than a walk in the park, whistling a catchy tune, showing “swag” on the street. It suggests that Parkinson’s is not that old , decrepit disease that has been with us for 200+ years but it’s just “swagger”. Get out on the streets all you PwP and strut your stuff. The ad feels like it belittles the disease.
When I first heard my neurologist’s diaagnosis, I’m pretty sure he didn’t say “It’s not Parkinson’s, It’s Swagger” -though I confess I wasn’t hearing everything he said through my tears that day.
I believe that this speaks more to the experience of those who are young and early on in their disease progression. They may be inspired to draw upon any “swag” reserves they may have and flaunt it on Main Street! As for me, after 24+ years, my “swag” tank has run dry. I’ve got to focus on putting one foot down in front of another, avoiding any missteps and maintaining my balance. I can’t afford to have falls like I’ve had of late – though inevitably I will. If you happen to see me fall, be forewarned, it’s not swagger, it’s Parkinson’s. Even if I’m listening to Beck.
Over the years, I’ve watched with interest as Michael J Fox’s career, and in particular, his diagnosis with Parkinson’s Disease unfolded. I’ve read all his books and have followed his work on behalf of the Michael J Fox Foundation. I even had the opportunity to pose a question to him on a live blog and hung out together for a week last year in his hometown of Vancouver! 1
He has been front and center in several of my blogs throughout the years including What if there is no cure? and This is a blog about Michael J Fox! I don’t want to dredge up all the sordid details of why I was not his number one fan but I do want to express why today i have a different view.
In the past 20+ years, Fox and the Michael J Fox Foundation, have spurred a copious amount of research into Parkinson’s Disease. The Foundation’s initial mandate was to find a cure for PD and put itself out of business in 10 years. Today a cure remains elusive and the Foundation has become somewhat of a monolith. Yet Fox acknowledges that these early goals were aspirational and science was not as clean or simplistic – that we sometimes learn more by failures. Our knowledge base of PD has grown substantially, as has public awareness of PD.
Without a doubt, a lot of this can be attributed to Fox himself – he’s an extremely likeable character. He’s well spoken and articulate, entertaining and good humoured. He is determined and tenacious in his PD work. He shows a real understanding of his disease and an admirable level of acceptance.
“The doctor said to me ‘You don’t win this, you lose,’ ” Fox said. “I like to win, I don’t like to waste my time with stuff, I like to go after it, and so that was the dilemma I faced. If I really learned from this, it was to learn how to lose well.“2
As his Parkinson’s has advanced, he hasn’t let up. It is very obvious how his body has been ravaged by PD and yet he continues to dedicate himself to his work. Upon viewing Still, I was struck by the intensity he has given to the task at hand – even in the face of adversity – for the duration he has. At the same time, he and his wife have raised what appears to be a good family grounded in love, empathy and caring. No small an accomplishment for even the most able amongst us.
Certainly, as my condition has deteriorated, I have had more challenges, have become more isolated, and less able to be involved in my community. This only heightens my newfound respect for Fox. So, my apologies. I’m sorry Michael. I now have no doubt that the world will be a better place for Michael J Fox having lived in it.
Thank you.
“Hung out together” as in were visiting in the city at the sametime! ↩︎↩︎
With the release of a new feature film titled Still, Michael J Fox was interviewed last year by CBC. In this 23 minute segment, he reflects on making the film and sharing his journey with Parkinson’s disease in such a public way. This really whet my appetite to see Still! (now streaming on Apple TV).
The CBC link includes some preview clips from the movie and I encourage you to watch it if you can. In the next few days I’ll publish my blog and explain the reasons why my thinking has changed about MJF!
A few weeks ago I wrote of my tentative steps back into blogging about living with PD. I say “tentative” only because I’m uncertain about whether my return is in fact an actual return to the same kind of blogging I had been doing for some 8 or 9 years – albeit from a fresh, hopefully more learned perspective. Or should I take my writing to a different platform – a different focus altogether? Or perhaps not at all. These are some of the things I’ve been grappling with.
Over time, I talked with family, friends, PwP, and other bloggers and writers. I’ve read and received a number of pieces that speak to some of the questions I have. I wish I had definitive answers but I don’t.
There was, however, one voice that reached out to me that I wanted to reference here. A few months ago, I came across a piece written by a man from London (UK) named Jon Stamford. We’re roughly the same age and have had PD for a similar length of time. He’s a scholar, a writer and long-time advocate in the UK for PD.. He’s written numerous books, blogs, and edited an international magazine called ” On The Move ”. That’s where our paths crossed a number of years ago when I was invited to submit an article for consideration for publication.
In March of this year, he wrote a blog that somewhat startled me entitled “Signing Off”. While I found the title and general tenor to be at times discouraging, I thought he very accurately captured the thoughts and feelings of many living and struggling with PD today. I know it was one voice that called out from the sidelines to me as i grappled with the decision to continue.
As you’ll see, Jon and I have arrived at different “conclusions” but I wanted to acknowledge his contribution to the debate. Here’s a large excerpt from Jon’s blog, reprinted with his permission. The battle may be over for Jon, but the war goes on.
For the last seventeen years I have had Parkinson’s (PD). Yes, I know I probably had it before diagnosis. It’s not a competition. There are no yardsticks to compare each other’s suffering. Simple fact – some get it worse than others. I consider myself one of the luckier ones. But it has been one of the enduring agonies of this condition that I have watched friends fall by the wayside. The journey is littered with the lost, comrades in arms who drew a weaker hand than I. Few things are more heartbreaking than to see close friends tortured beyond repair, their voices fading into the long silence.
Some shade into darkness quicker than others. Some are tortured by the private agonies of dystonia, others dance to that ridiculous self-parody of walking that we call dyskinesia, forced to endure the cruel laughter and humiliation, ultimately too weary to explain to the disinterested. Even for those untouched by such vicissitudes, there are still further miseries in store.
.…. And there’s the rub. I have said everything I wanted to say, offered every crumb of advice I could conjure, and cracked every joke I know.
I could carry on, re-treading and re-purposing old ground for what may be a new audience. Not a bad way to spend my time. And, with a little effort, I could easily delude myself that this still represented a service to our PD community. Truth is it doesn’t.
For me, PD is a journey but not in the way you might think. It is no mere progression and intensification of symptoms, though those are a parallel path. No, the journey as such is the transformation of blind optimism into realism. The journey essentially of acceptance.
For many within the PD community, acceptance is a dirty word. I know plenty who might argue that acceptance amounts to an admission of defeat. I don’t see it that way. To my mind, acceptance is the realisation that I cannot change everything. Some things will be beyond my ability to alter, whether by healthy eating, medication, exercise and so on. Acceptance for me represents the acknowledgement that energy spent railing against the injustice of PD is not energy well spent. Fighting PD is sapping. In my book, acceptance is a redeployment of one’s resources where one can reasonably expect benefit. In the same way Russia burnt its cities ahead of the Wehrmacht’s approach, prepared to concede ground and better use the resources they had to preserve the country. So it is with PD. Don’t fight the battles you can’t win.
It has taken me some seventeen years to grasp this fundamental truth, to reach this personal nirvana. Acceptance is the path to survival not to defeat. I don’t want to ‘fight’, kicking and screaming against this unseen enemy. There are better ways of spending that energy.
I have written books, given lectures, been part of panels, workgroups and advisory boards. I’ve advocated till I’m blue in the face. I have been a neuroscientist, a researcher, writer and adviser. Sure, others have done more. But I have done all I can. And at the end of the day I’ve put in my shift. I’ve given all I had. And now I want to turn away from writing about PD. It’s time for younger men and women to spell out their agenda, to raise their banners and and to lead their armies.
This, such as it is, is my baton to pass on to you. Run. Run like the wind. There is a whole world out there. Life is the ultimate journey and we never pass the same way twice. Thank you for reading. My watch is ended.
A few posts ago (or more precisely over 7 years ago!) I wrote of the varied and many ways Parkinson’s has impacted my life. Sadly, many of these ailments go hand in hand with Parkinson’s Disease. Although each person’s own experience will be different, many with PD will experience some, if not many, of these. Here, from that blog, O Lord Won’t You Buy Me A Mercedes-Benz, is a copy of that list.
dyskenisis (involuntary movement)
impediments in walking (balance, stumbling)
impaired hand-eye coordination and depth perception
reduced visual acuity
weakened voice
blank facial expression( the PD mask)
muscle cramping
drooling
dry mouth
dental problems
choking
insomnia
over-active bladder
weight gain and weight loss (more gain than loss though!)
loss of sense of smell and taste
fatigue
rigidity and restricted mobility
postural problems
weakened dexterity
cognitive impairment
mood changes
depression
social withdrawal
gastro-intestinal problems
colitis
As I noted at the time, I didn’t put this list out there to solicit sympathy or evoke empathy. I think you will agree that it is a clear demonstration that PD is much more than solely a movement disorder.
In the 7 years since I penned this list, how have these symptoms changed? Generally speaking, I continue to experience everything on that list yet, over time, some of these have become more severe while others might be described as annoyances – ever-present but I’ve learned to cope. Some I struggle with in private. Some bring more public indignation.
Besides significant restrictions in my mobility – brought on by advanced PD, waning effectiveness of PD medication and aging- I recently discovered a new and unwelcomed “twist” on my PD. I stepped out of the shower and caught a glimpse of myself in the mirror. While this “check in the mirror” may sound banal to some of you, my guess is that a lot of people with PD don’t spend a heck of a long time looking at mirrors. There’s too much PD has taken from us…too much scarring of our bodies already that we don’t need reminding of!
Nevertheless, this glance was concerning. I stepped up closer to the mirror, straightened myself to confront the visage that faced me. But I couldn’t straighten out. My legs were relatively straight. My arms, when not flailing about, could be settled into a straight position for a time. But my entire torso was tilted or leaning to the right perhaps 15-20 degrees.
Huh? What’s up with that? How did this happen? How long have I had this lean? Could I do anything about it? Was I destined to live out my years looking like a sideways Quasimodo?
As I was to learn, this is known in the Parkinson’s community as Pisa Syndrome and is defined as “a lateral bending of the trunk with a tendency to lean to one side. It is a frequent and often disabling complication of Parkinson’s disease” (Lancet, 2016). There is no clear cause for it nor is there a consensus on treatment. It may be reversible but again there are no clear strategies nor substantive evidence to lead to this conclusion.
I have never been of the mind that I should feel shame or embarrassment about the way that I look, move or walk. I’ve even enjoyed the odd moment like I experienced once at a festival where an assembled crowd parted on the field to make way for me pass. They didn’t know what to expect as I lurched forward unsure of my step and unstable in my walk and my flailing arms just barely holding on to drinks! I recognize that, as my movements become more restricted, more strange glances will come my way. Same too with shuffling feet and a variable gait. Now add a twisted torso. Pisa Syndrome has already made a marked difference in my appearance and one that I’m sure will bring me further consternation as time goes by. For the moment, if you’ll indulge me, I’m just going to avoid mirrors for a little bit.
1950s-1960s Couple Man Woman Sitting On Porch In Rocking Chairs, Posterazzi
Who would have guessed that my self-imposed break from this blog would last not a month, not a year, but almost 5 years!
As frequent readers may recall (and there were at least a few!) I was experiencing increasing demands and changes in my Parkinson’s Disease after 20+ years. I also felt somewhat discouraged that there seemed to be very little significant progress being made in the treatment of PD – certainly not in the elusive quest for a cure! Resources and community supports were changing. Social networks changed along with them and , of course, we would all experience the devastating impact of COVID on our world. Increased socialization has been an especially heavy burden to bear for people with PD.
Unfortunately, that isolation leads to feelings of loneliness, loss, doubts of self-worth, apathy and depression. I questioned the value of my blog and whether adding my voice would have some positive purpose or merely add to the cacophony of voices already clamoring on. After some time, I came to believe I had said everything I wanted to say. It had served its purpose and run its course. I could have taken the route that so many bloggers seem to take and that is to repeat the same, tired topics. Put a different spin on the same old. Add a new graphic to the same old. Nothing new to say? No problem – just go with the same old same old!
Of course, I was not going to go with the same old. I did need a break though. As time went on, I became less inclined to write about PD. I wondered whether or not I’d ever revive the blog and, to be honest, I still struggle with that notion. Yet out of this apparent incongruity emerges this post. Just me taking the time to share a few thoughts with you. C’est la vie say the old folks, it goes to show you never can tell!
For a variety of reasons, I’ve been feeling melancholy of late. I’ve been having a difficult time putting “pen to paper” to explain it but I’ve been trying. Perhaps it’s because I’m noticing more my PD’s progression. Perhaps it’s because I’ve had yet another fall that’s set me back. Perhaps its the thought of yet another fall (as in autumnal) to come – and the dreaded winter to follow – when summer is but a few days old. Perhaps it’s just an aging thing. I will attempt to tease this out more fully in a future post.
For the moment, I need to take a summer recess from writing my blog. I’ll continue to share bits of news I find of interest and appreciate if you’ll keep sharing with me. For now, it’s time to get outside. Get some sun. Have a great summer and see you back here in the fall!
P.S. How synchronistic that I get a Facebook notice the other day of a “new” video from Marianne Faithfull – haven’t heard this in a while but it captures, at least in part, where I’m at these days!
Growing evidence suggests Parkinson’s disease starts in gut
The GUARDIAN, JUNE 26, 2019
The latest findings, based on studies in mice, back up a long-held theory that abnormally folded alpha-synuclein might start off in the gut and spread to the brain. Photograph: Spectral/Alamy
Evidence that Parkinson’s disease may start off in the gut is mounting, according to new research showing proteins thought to play a key role in the disease can spread from the gastrointestinal tract to the brain.
The human body naturally forms a protein called alpha-synuclein which is found, among other places, in the brain in the endings of nerve cells. However, misfolded forms of this protein that clump together are linked to damage to nerve cells, a deterioration of the dopamine system and the development of problems with movement and speech – hallmarks of Parkinson’s disease Read full article here.
Gut-Dwelling Bacterium Consumes Parkinson’s Drug
Posted on NIH Director’s Blog by Dr. Francis Collins
Scientists continue to uncover the many fascinating ways in which the trillions of microbes that inhabit the human body influence our health. Now comes yet another surprising discovery: a medicine-eating bacterium residing in the human gut that may affect how well someone responds to the most commonly prescribed drug for Parkinson’s disease.
There have been previous hints that gut microbes might influence the effectiveness of levodopa (L-dopa), which helps to ease the stiffness, rigidity, and slowness of movement associated with Parkinson’s disease. Now, in findings published in Science, an NIH-funded team has identified a specific, gut-dwelling bacterium that consumes L-dopa [1]. The scientists have also identified the bacterial genes and enzymes involved in the process. Read full article here.